Review:
Some years ago, there was a move by Prof. Alice Coleman's Land
Utilisation Survey to create a new map of the UK based on 'scapes.
This 'scape' theory suggested that land use could be divided
into three main categories and two transitional zones. The argument
was simple - land use change occurs at the margins and it is
here that the work should focus. That work (at least according
to internet research) is now defunct and there seems little
to show for the ideas. However, the notion of marginal change
has been around for longer and now, in the guise of the 'peri-urban'
returns in this text to highlight issues pertinent to urban
change.
The
cases described here are taken from the developing nations -
those where urban change is most extreme and where resources
are least. The aim is to describe such change and its impacts
and to demonstrate how it can be more sustainably managed.To
achieve this, the book is divided into five parts. The first
of these seeks to define the concept and the range of topics
it encompasses. For these purposes, the first chapter is the
most useful especially for the novice because it outlines the
key concepts and highlights the remaining chapters. The defence
of the peri-urban is strong: it it argued that it is the main
place of change in the global South and that is there that policy
needs to focus. The three subsequent chapters in this part look
at some of the main ideas and organisations involved. Chapter
two looks at the work of SCOPE
(the Scientific Committee on Problems of the Environment) which
has contributed much to the development
of this topic as well as contributors to this book. Chapter
three examines research into this area which can inform policy
whilst chapter four comes from the other direction to assess
how well policy fits in with research. Part two looks at the
opportunities presented by the growing urban situation rather
than the threats contained. The common theme is food production.
As with earlier-developing cities such as London, the opportunity
exists to create primary production close to the market. Although
not referred to as the 'market gardening' of the global South
there are striking parallels. The range of cases is interesting
here going from vegetables to marketing strategies to cattle.
There are also interesting cases showing how scale impacts upon
the work and how some groups live by expanding the ways they
earn money (from pastoralism to a range of jobs including office
work). Part three moves on to examine cases of peri-urban management,
how it is implemented and how it does/doesn't work. As one might
expect, in areas of considerable need and few resources there
are going to be difficulties encountered. The part starts with
a look at the problems of policy-making. Next, we see some of
the social and environmental costs created by the construction
of this zone. Of course, the zone isn't just for the people
that live there, it's also a zone of change for other urban
dwellers. Transport plans which might help some can also create
problems for the peri-urban dwellers especially the poor. At
this stage, one might think that the text is just reporting
issues that have been found but there is far more to this text.
The sub-title of the book "approaches to sustainable natural
and human resource use" shows the direction that the writers
are taking - this is not just reporting policy, the aim is to
inform policy along a specific paradigm. That this is going
to prove difficult is the theme of the final two chapters in
the section looking at the problems in W. Africa. Part four
takes all this work and tries to suggest ways forward. In some
ways this is 'back to the future' as cases suggest that "appropriate-scale"
technology be used in recycling schemes showing that the (Intermediate
Technology) IT work in the 1970s was not lost. Another contribution
suggests the use of sustainability indicators to produce GIS-style
work that can show the nature, rate and location of change.
The two final chapters in this part look at an IT project in
Kenya and the value of citizen participation in Nigeria. Part
five is a single, reflective chapter summarising the work and
its contribution to the wider debate.
This
is a very useful text about a key area in urban development.
The construction of text into overview, resource use, issues
and solutions makes the debate far easier to understand. Since
developing world cities and issues are a key teaching focus
this book becomes a great guide to the work. Senior students
would find much of interest but, lacking the visual elements
of many texts, this work might be more suited to educators to
use as part of their own work. There's a very wide variety of
examples both conceptually and geographically. For those beyond
the school system, this text should be seen as a key reader
in areas such as sustainability and resource management.