Review:
Part of the problem with global warming is get get people to
understand it exists and then to reach a consensus on what might
be happening, when and the extent of change. The other part
of the problem and one that is only just getting into public
consciousness is the need to do something about it. The need
for action is obvious but until recently tangible proof (or
directions to go in) have been lacking. What we are seeing now
is an attempt to get the burgeoning amount of work into the
mainstream. One such area is carbon trading. Despite a rash
of adverts and media copy in the last two years there have been
projects going for almost a decade. One could argue that it's
now time to let more people into the "secret" of dealing
with global warming.
The
word 'dealing' here is deliberate. There is one strand of action
that suggests since free-market thinking got us into this situation
it ought to get us out. Whilst not entirely certain of the logic
there are certainly enough cases where some (increasingly sizeable)
money has been put where the corporate mouth is. In turn, there
are organisations, such as the authors' Ecosystemmarketwatch
site that have been monitoring progress. This book is one such
product. For the uninitiated, chapter one is a crash course
in voluntary carbon markets. These are largely smaller-scale
systems run without the considerable legal tracking of Wall
St, FTSE etc. but which seeks to offset the carbon produced
by human activity. Once the scene has been set, chapter two
moves in to an overview of how such markets work. Since these
are still very new the processes are fluid but there's enough
agreement on how to trade. Basically, the supply chain generates
the pollution levels which are then verified. Carbon credits
(offsets) are purchased to nullify the effect. So, if a company
produces x tonnes of CO2 then it purchases forestry credits
which would take up that carbon in the form of growing trees.
These credits can be traded through a stock-market like any
other commodity. What makes this market different is that it
is undertaken for reasons other than profit - because it's voluntary
people join in for philanthropic motives or as a desire for
corporate social responsibility. Chapter three moves on to look
at a more complex scene - comparing these early carbon markets
with renewable energy certificates in the US. The idea is that
by investing in 'green energy' you can also reduce carbon emissions.
It's the consideration of this element that makes this market
far more complex than straight-forward trading markets: not
producing is the same as reducing if you want to lose something!
Chapter four takes a step back. After the race through the scene,
the authors/editors have asked others active in the scene to
give their accounts of the carbon market's future. Naturally,
as you would expect, they are upbeat but they are also cautious
- there's no automatic right for these to succeed and there
are many practical and theoretical issues that need to be solved.
A very brief last chapter points to the future and what we might
expect. This is followed but an unusually large set of appendices
which detail a range of project types, actual examples, standards,
credit sellers and institutional buyers. Many of these cases
mention names, websites, amounts etc. so they should be easy
to trace for more information.
From
a vague idea a few years ago this has become a serious player
in the market. Current concerns over global warming should not
dampen enthusiasm too much. Here is an example of a conventional
market taking the idea of ecosystem services on board and proving
practically (as many of us realised theoretically) that it is
possible to be green and profitable. This book is a
brief roller-coaster ride through the system. As such it needs
some prior knowledge hence its designation for educators rather
than students (who would find much to be excited about). Overall,
a very good introduction to what promises to be a growth area.