Review:
The issue of indigenous knowledge has become increasingly prominent
over the last few years. Indigenous (or traditional ecological)
knowledge can be a powerful change agent but there are many
barriers in the way. In an ideal world this knowledge would
be used by the people for their benefit but there are too many
examples of it being taken without recompense. However, cost/benefit
is not the only issue here. Traditional owners have a connection
to the land and sea that can provide useful management insights
if properly understood (which is where the problems start building
up). What is needed is a text which tries to bring together
traditional and contemporary ways of seeing and doing and find
out what each can contribute. The result, as seen here, is an
excellent text.
One
of the biggest gaps is understanding and communication. Traditional
and contemporary worldviews do not come from the same perspective
and so here is our first stumbling block. It takes the first
chapter to unravel a few of the more important points and show
how traditional knowledge 'sees' the world. Chapter two takes
that one stage further with a discussion of how the field developed
with the subsequent chapter examining the intellectual underpinnings
of traditional knowledge (from both perspectives as neither
is seen as the 'perfect' answer). Traditional knowledge was
never intended to be abstract in the sense of pure learning
- it was designed to keep a group alive. As such it would be
seen as an empirical science (where failure could be deadly).
Chapter four reinforces this message with a range of examples
from around the world. The next three chapters could be seen
as a case study in one indigenous group's study and use of and
belief in the environment and its resources. The Cree Indians
are the focus of this major study and the depth of the material
produced shows the extent of their knowledge. Starting with
a philosophical perspective of their knowledge and belief, the
author takes us through the system as it actually works for
them and the ways in which their knowledge can be equated with
a more Western-oriented resources management. There is no doubt
that indigenous knowledge has a considerable history. Given
this it would be useful to access it's workings to see what
it might offer to contemporary problems. In another series of
cases, we are shown alternative perspectives on global warming,
holistic analysis and knowledge management. In all cases there
is more complexity than one might imagine. It is very clear
that this is no simple worldview but a very rich one and one,
by these examples, that could usefully add to conventional ways
of knowing. The two final chapters focus on the use of and integration
with contemporary management. Chapter 11 focusses on the issues
that we need to face in dealing with traditional knowledge from
acceptance of its strengths and weaknesses to our understanding
of the people whose knowledge it is. This is confronting for
it offers no simple solution but shows the true complexity that
needs to be addressed. Finally, chapter 12 shows us how we can
benefit from a greater use of traditional knowledge and how
the traditional owners can gain from this interaction.
This
is an excellent text shedding much light on a neglected (but
growing) area of study. Traditional knowledge has much to offer
but conventional science needs to be more aware. It's a confronting
story with no easy answers but it is essential that we try.
As a start, we need to be far more aware of the richness of
traditional knowledge and this awareness needs to filter through
to our education system. This book is a great start- it should
be seen as a crucial text for anyone working in this area.