Review:
Space and spatial representation are two of the big issues in
ecology and earth sciences. Although they could be seen as central
to any environmental study (where else does ecology actually
happen?) there is an ambivalence to much of the published work.
At a time when the need to realise interactivity in all ecological
spheres both theoretical and applied has never been more pressing,
the actual output remains modest. Into this area we have the
author's current work. This reviewer first met his ideas with
the seminal Land
Mosaics published in 1995. Like all really revolutionary
ideas it appeared quite simple - land must be seen as a patchwork
of interacting areas. Since that time he has continued research
in a variety of areas but in this text there is the potential
for yet another groundbreaking analysis. Like Land Mosaics
the premise is deceptively simple - urban areas are impacting
upon natural systems but can be planned to work sustainably.
As such it combines ecology and urban planning and shows, through
the use of detailed case studies, how settlements can be better
planned.
We
start with an introduction that revisits an old theme and helps
us understand a new. The notion of multiple scales is one we've
met before but the idea of urban area/region/bioregion etc.
is newer and gets more attention. By the end of the chapter
the reader understands the nature of the study being attempted
here. Chapter two continues the introductory theme by examining
the concept of planning and how it operates. Cities have economics
close to their heart for that helps the area develop but, as
we see in chapter three, there are other dimensions as well
e.g. social, cultural and environmental. The aim is to get the
reader to appreciate a wider picture for the 'urban' concept.
A final chapter continues the ideas taken up at the beginning
but this time the focus is on 'natural' ecosystems and ecology.
By focussing on community, aquatic and soil ecosystems along
with climate we get to see how ecology, far from being apart
from the city is vitally a part of it. This is reinforced with
a section in this chapter on green spaces - the 'natural' world
allowed into settlements providing it is contained. Chapter
five starts the case study part of the text. The idea was that
38 urban regions would be studied and their impact recorded
so that lessons in sustainable planning could be derived. The
first aspect is defining and describing the cities (chapter
5). The list is extensive and geographically diverse: Chicago
to Cairo to Ulaan Bataar. To help the reader understand the
complexities, differences and similarities, a series of coloured
maps (using a single unified key) is put into this chapter to
demonstrate how the cities have developed and the area over
which their demands are met. The next stage is to gather key
data on the natural systems of urban areas. Starting with caveats
on scale, chapter six covers nature (patches, connections, areas),
agriculture and water, showing how each of these change with
urban area other variables. The overall aim is to both chart
degree and select those factors which might be of influence
later in the argument. Chapter seven continues this research
focussing on the built environment - roads, infrastructure,
transport, other cities and urban regions. These two chapters
show the variability of the city. Chapter 8 ties this in which
models of urbanisation and urban development. The idea is to
show, firstly, the variability in land use and mosaics around
cities and, secondly, how this fits into some of the more influential
urban models. To this point the book has gradually outlined
the key ideas - study regions and parameters, data and models.
Chapter 9 suggests how we can plan our urban regions to be more
sustainable - to use the ecology of the area rather than go
against it. The chapter describes features such as patch size,
corridors, transport and communities and outlines the best planning
principles for each. Chapter 10 applies this thinking to the
single case study of Barcelona. Chapter 11 gathers the material
that has been generated dividing them into sections like settings,
lessons from Barcelona and the impact of scale. The final part
of the chapter shows which of these might have positive, negative
or 'interesting' impacts on urban design. In this part, the
various parameters are noted and the urban regions matching
the parameter are listed. A final chapter tries to show which
route to take and some of the issues we face along the way.
This
is a 'big picture' book in many ways. Its breadth of research
is outstanding. The questions put and answers given are highly
thought provoking. It should be seen as a 'must read' book for
educators, urban planners, teacher educators and anyone trying
to understand a sustainable urban future without the usual sustainability
rhetoric. This stands alongside Land Mosaics as one
of the most influential texts published in a long time.